Thursday, 13 Dhu al-Qi'dah 1442 | 2021/06/24
Time now: (M.M.T)
Main menu
Main menu
Political Questions

Political Questions (124)

  Answer to Question Latest Political Developments in the Syrian Scene (Translated)

It was published that America and Turkey signed an agreement to train the so-called moderate members... Does this mean that America is about to find an alternate to Bashar, thus it is preparing a suitable force on ground to support him, in addition to air support? Or is it just to buy time with training for a year or two... until America finds an alternative? In other words, does this mean that the alternative is close so they are preparing support for him, or is the alternative far, so they are buying time in training to prepare the alternative? May Allah (swt) reward you.


Answer to the Question Relations between America and India, led by Modi, and the Kashmir Issue The Relationship of China and Afghanistan and the Taliban (Translated)  

First, the latest meeting between Obama and Modi has received intensive media coverage, but it did not result in any real decision, it seems that there is still a problem between the United States and between India and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Can you point out the disputed issues between the two parties?

Second, given that the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in India and Nawaz's party in Pakistan, are both loyal to the United States, and that the issue of Kashmir is draining India, then why is India stalling in resolving the Kashmir problem?


Question and Answer The Jewish Entity and its Bond to America! (Translated)

In Netanyahu's speech before the US Congress on 03/03/2015, he affirmed his rejection of what America is conducting with Iran regarding Iran's nuclear program. This was during his visit, which was not according to the usual protocol, it was without permission, not even of Obama or his Democratic Party in Congress, what was described by some observers as an insult to Obama, does this mean that American relations with the Jewish state has entered the stage of severing relations or a state of hostility? Are these events related to the elections in the Jewish state and in America? What is expected from the results of the elections in both countries? Jazak Allah khair.


Question and Answer Regarding the Minsk Agreement and the Escalation of Events in Ukraine (Translated)

There has been a noticeable escalation in the interaction of Merkel and Hollande with Putin and then converging in Minsk with the presence of the President of Ukraine... and after their meeting they reached an agreement in Minsk to a ceasefire in eastern Ukraine as of Sunday, 15/02/2015 CE, and the establishment of a demilitarized zone. The Minsk agreement states that the Ukrainian authorities and the rebels in the east of the country have two days after the ceasefire to start the withdrawal of heavy weapons from the front line. Allowing for the establishment of a buffer zone


  Question and Answer Regarding the Postponement of the Elections in Nigeria (Translated)

On 8/2/2015 CE, the Nigerian Electoral Commission announced the postponement of the presidential and legislative elections which were scheduled to take place on 14th February 2015; they have been postponed to 28th March 2015 under the pretext of internal security concerns... Is this the case? Or is this delay is for international reasons? And if so, which countries are influencing this delay? And what is expected for this election?


Question and Answer Developments in Yemen - Salman bin Abdul Aziz Assumes the Rule in Saudi (Translated)

There are interesting events in Yemen and Saudi Arabia; the Houthis have taken over Sanaa, the government resigned and then the President of the Republic on the evening of 22/01/2015 ... Then King Abdullah in Saudi Arabia, died the morning of Friday, 23/01/2015 and was succeeded by King Salman bin Abdul Aziz. My question is in twofold: I: Are the events in Yemen still as issued by the party on 1/10/2014? And what is the expected solution? II: Does the receipt of Salman Bin Abdul Aziz of power after King Abdullah change in the policy of Saudi Arabia or have matters remained the same?


Answer to Question Causes for the Sudden Decrease in Oil Prices (Translated)

Media outlets have published this Wednesday, 07/01/2015 CE that Brent Crude Oil prices hit $49.66 per barrel, as too did the American crude oil, falling to around $47 per barrel, given that oil prices in 2014 have reached $115 a barrel at the beginning of summer in June in 2014. Then returned to gradually decrease until it reached at the beginning of winter, (at the end of December 2014) to $60 a barrel, and even lower than that, when the prices of West Texas crude oil reached $58.53, and here in the first week of January 2015, it reached to about $50, i.e. more than 50% decrease within five months! What are the causes for this sudden fall in oil prices? And what is expected for oil prices in the future?


Answer to the Question: Motives behind Global Struggle To: Ahmad Fuad Fuad (Translated)

In the book Political Concepts, under the chapter "Motives Behind Global Struggle" on page 30 English version (page 54 Arabic version), the first line on the first paragraph mentions: "Since the dawn of history to the day of judgement, the motives of the nations for global struggle are either pride and the desire for sovereignty or the pursuance of material interests."


  The Answer to the Question: Is the work to establish the Islamic State limited to the Arab countries only? To: Malik Murad (Translated)


As-Salaamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullah Wa Barakaatuhu

I pray that Allah grant you success and bless us with the victory by your hands our Ameer, soon Inshallah, this matter belongs to Allah Alone, and we bear witness you are the best successor to the best predecessors

In the book: Concepts of Hizb ut Tahrir on page 73 (English version) it mentions:

"Carrying the Islamic da'wah and the political struggle for its cause can be undertaken only in the society which the party has defined as its area for activity (majal).Hizb ut-Tahrir considers the society in all the Islamic lands to be one society because its entire cause lies in one case, Islam. However it takes the Arab lands that are a part of the Islamic Lands as a starting point. It considers the establishment of an Islamic state in the Arab countries as a nucleus for the Islamic state as a natural step."

It was also mentioned in the book: Structuring of a Party on pages 6 - 7:

"Therefore, it is only natural for the Islamic State to be re-established in the Arab territories, so that it will serve as a nucleus for the Islamic State which will encompass all Islamic lands. Though carrying the Islamic Da'wah in the Arab territories is necessary it is also necessary for the Islamic Da'wah to reach out to the rest of the Islamic world.

Notwithstanding this, initiating the work in the Arab territories does not mean that no work be done outside Arab territories before unifying the Arab territories in the Islamic State. The work must be carried out in the Arab territories to re-establish the Islamic State, then the State will grow and encompass the neighboring territories, regardless of whether they consist of Arabs or not".

Can it be understood from these texts that the target countries we work in to establish the Khilafah "Caliphate" are the Arab countries only, and that the work in rest of the non-Arab countries is for the purpose of carrying the Dawah and not for the establishment of the Islamic State there? Especially after mentioning that the nucleus of the coming Islamic state, soon by the permission of Allah, must be in the Arab countries first and then it expands to the rest of the Islamic countries.

Please explain what is the meaning of these texts specifically, I found some confusion in understanding them.

May Allah Bless you our Ameer and May Allah make us victorious by you and bring the victory by your hands.




Wa Alaikum us Salaam Wa Rahmatullah Wa Barakaatuhu,

It must not be understood from the quoted texts from the two books, Concepts of Hizb ut Tahrir and Structuring of a Party, that the work to establish the State is limited to the Arab countries. Both texts mention that it is only natural, in origin the State be established in the Arab countries and not in others, this is because the Arabic language is the language of Islam, it is essential in understanding Islam and carrying out Ijtihad, this is why it is out of priority and proximity that the State be established in the Arab countries, that speak the Arabic language.

But this might not be achieved, and the State may be established in non-Arab countries, since the whole Islamic world is suitable for the establishment of the Khilafah "Caliphate" State, even though the priority is for the Arab countries. The Hizb does not limit its work to establish the State in the Arab countries, but it is also working to establish the State in non-Arab countries. The Hizb was founded in Arab countries, and worked there, the Majal (field of work to establish the state) was there initially because this is where the Hizb is and it is the place of their work, but when the Dawah grew outside the Arab countries and found a solid ground outside the Arab world, the Hizb extended its Majal and began to work to establish the Khilafah "Caliphate" in the Muslim countries, whether it was Arab or non-Arab, if the natural state is achieved and it is established in the Arab countries, then all  praise be to Allah, and if it is established in the other Islamic countries  it is also all praise be to Allah.

(وَرَبُّكَ يَخْلُقُ مَا يَشَاءُ وَيَخْتَارُ)

"And your Lord creates what He wills and chooses" [Al-Qasas: 68]

And we seek assistance from Allah (swt).


Your brother,


Ata Bin Khalil Abu Al-Rashtah


The link to the answer from the Ameer's Facebook page



Question and Answer Recent Developments in Yemen, in Particular the Signing of the Peace and National Partnership Agreement (Translated)

The recent developments in Yemen were ambiguous to me, particularly the signing of the Peace and National Partnership Agreement on 21/09/2014, as though these developments have shuffled the papers... How were the Houthis able to reach Sanaa and lead its power and influence without effective resistance from the authorities? Does it imply that the influence of the British in Yemen has ended, and America that supports the Houthis has become the influential initiator in Yemen or is it the sharing of influence? Please clarify these matters, May Allah reward you with goodness.

Subscribe to this RSS feed

Site Categories



Muslim Lands

Muslim Lands