In our books we find the narration of Saad bin Moaz’s verdict on the Jews of Bani Qurayza; to kill their men and confiscate their money and take their women as captives, although the decisive rule on the prisoners of war in the Qur’an is either Mann (kindness) or Fida (ransom): Is this ruling by Saad in contradiction with the rule of the Qur’an and thus we must drop this…

In the book of the “Islamic Personality” Volume III (The Origins of Jurisprudence), under the section "There is no ruling before the statement of the Shar’’" on page 28 (Arabic), I quote the text: “There is no action from man, or anything related with man’s action, except that it has a ruling in Shariah, and there is no ruling except by the presence of an evidence related to it specifically…

Regarding the death penalty for Muhson, is Qothie categorized in Fiqh Islam? There are some scholars such as Sheikh Abu Zahrah who do not categorize it as Hudud punishment. It is even supported by Sheikh Mustafa Zarqa who states that it is categorized in the sentence of Takzir. How do you think about this issue?

But does obedience to Allah and His Messenger oblige obedience to the Hizb in all the commands and Ijtihad (opinions) that you have reached, which have difference in opinion to what I adopted previously. I give the example of women’s awra in front of their mahrams and Muslim women. Some scholars have agreed that it is from the navel to the knee, as well the menstruating woman reciting the Qur'an…